Interim Research Products

The scholarly communication landscape, especially over the last five years, has been changing rapidly. A noteworthy “new kid on the block” that has recently seen a big increase in availability, visibility, and use, is a category of resource type often referred to as “Interim Research Products”.

Interim research products are basically research documents that are shared publicly prior to their final publication in a peer-reviewed scholarly journal. In other words – keeping in mind that there are multiple definitions by different stakeholders that continue to evolve in this space – they are: research products that become part of the public scientific record without yet having been confirmed by peer review.

Most common among them are preprints and preregistered protocols. Recent discussions of these two types of interim research products that may be of interest:

1: Xu J, Zhang L. Will Medical Preprints Change Oncology Practice? JAMA Oncol.2020 Feb 20. doi: 10.1001/jamaoncol.2019.5972. [Epub ahead of print] PubMed PMID:32077893. 

2: Schiavo JH. PROSPERO: An International Register of Systematic Review Protocols. Med Ref Serv Q. 2019 Apr-Jun;38(2):171-180. doi:10.1080/02763869.2019.1588072. PubMed PMID: 31173570.

Funding agencies like the National Institutes of Health (NIH), among others, have started encouraging the use of interim research products as they may potentially improve the rigor of research work and speed up the dissemination of research results, not to mention allow for more transparency in the research process.

For example, the rapid sharing and dissemination of research findings is a critical goal of the National Cancer Institute (NCI)’s Cancer Moonshot Initiative as a way to accelerate cancer research. Specified in their documentation is the requirement “that all publications and data resulting from Cancer Moonshot funded initiatives will be required to be immediately accessible“. 

From their Cancer Moonshot Public Access and Data Sharing Policy website: 

“Much of the urgency highlighted by the Cancer Moonshot and in the Blue Ribbon Panel’s recommendations to the National Cancer Advisory Board (NCAB) in 2016 emphasizes that the rapid availability of cancer publications and the primary data behind it promotes dissemination of new knowledge, enhances reproducibility, and accelerates the ability of researchers to build upon cancer research to make new discoveries.” 

With this aim in mind, the Cancer Moonshot Initiative uses a broader definition of “publication” and “publish” than is traditionally used on their funding information website, and one that is more inclusive of interim research products. More specifically:

  • Publication: A “Publication” includes (a) published research results in any manuscript that is peer-reviewed and accepted by a journal1 or (b) a complete and public draft of a scientific document (commonly referred to as preprint).2
  • Publish: To “Publish” means to report in a publicly accessible manner.

For more information about finding and citing interim research products, be sure to Ask Us at the MSK Library.

Using Google Scholar for COVID-19 Reseach

There is an abundance of COVID-19 related resources and search vehicles; they offer some overlapping and some unique opportunities, each having its own strengths and weaknesses. Google Scholar is one of these search vehicles.

One of the advantages of Google Scholar is its scope; searching Google Scholar can retrieve information from a variety of reputable sources at once, using the same search strategy. The sources include the full text of scholarly articles, as well as grey literature sources. Grey literature is not typically found via bibliographic databases such as PubMed, but rather is scattered on various websites, such as government and international agencies, scholarly societies and associations.

One of the major disadvantages of Google Scholar is the lack of transparency on the body of literature being searched and the sporadic nature of the search results. Please, note that some of the content retrievable by Google Scholar searches may appear there ahead of its record appearing in relevant databases, some may appear later, and some may not appear at all.

One useful tool for doing COVID-19 research using Google Scholar: they have provided direct links on their homepage to a variety of vetted sources and publishers that offered their COVID-19 articles free of charge during the outbreak.

As always with Google Scholar, you may also perform your own custom searches across all resources searchable via Google Scholar using its search box.

As we reported previously, besides simple searches with a space between the search terms, Google Scholar can be searched using Boolean Operators and nesting, although it does not allow truncating the keywords (e.g. with an asterisk as a wild card) in the same way bibliographic databases do.

You can combine COVID-19 related search terms, put them in parentheses, with the Boolean Operator “OR” and then combine this set of search terms, using an “AND” operator, with a different set of search terms, a single search term or a phrase (in double quotes).

A simplified example:
(“covid-19” OR “sars-cov-2” OR ncov OR ncovid) AND (“lung cancer” OR nsclc OR sclc)

Among the search results that Google Scholar retrieves are preprints from a variety of preprint servers (what are preprints and preprint servers?). To search one or multiple preprint servers through the Google Scholar interface, consider the following example of the search string typed in the Google Scholar search box:

(“covid-19” OR “sars-cov-2” OR ncov OR ncovid) AND (“lung cancer” OR nsclc OR sclc) AND (arxiv OR medrxiv OR biorxiv OR chemrxiv)

Note: While there is always concern about the validity of preprints, a recent Nature news article How swamped preprint servers are blocking bad coronavirus research describes how these servers are increasing the quality control of their research in the wake of the COVID-19 surge.

Google Scholar provides a couple of very basic tools, e.g. time period filters, located on the left-hand side of the screen. For example, you can limit your search to 2020 by clicking on “Since 2020.” However, be aware that clicking on Sort by date would not just sort chronologically, but also decrease the number of search results (which is not typical in most databases), limiting them to the few most recent months.

You can also use the My Library feature (linked from the menu located next to the Google Scholar logo) to save articles to your account (to save an article you need to click the star icon below the search result) and Create alert feature, which allows you to save your search and receive search results via e-mail (the alerts could be daily if the new content retrievable by your search strategy appears in Google Scholar). Other tools, such as sending your search results to the citation management program, etc., are also available.

Takeaway:

Google Scholar may serve as a complementary search engine for COVID-19 related research by searching the full text of the content from multiple academic, government, and international sources.

New Anesthesiology Service Group Added to Synapse

A new custom group was created to track the publications of the faculty in MSK’s Anesthesiology Service. This department is responsible for all anesthesiology given in both inpatient and outpatient settings across MSK, and joins the existing Critical Care Medicine group in Synapse under the parent group, Anesthesiology and Critical Care Medicine

Groups in Synapse pull the publications of selected author profiles into a single collection, allowing you to view and track the research coming out of our various departments and services. Administrators and authors can use the groups to create bibliographies for grant applications and annual reports. They can also access metrics such as total number of papers, author position in the paper (last author and first author), and author h-index through the new Research Activity Dashboard (RAD).

For more information, or to start your own Synapse Group, please contact Jeanine McSweeney.